WILL COVID-19 BE THE CATALYST - icon
Posted on 19 May 2020 by Barry Standish
COVID-19

Will COVID-19 be the catalyst for the most devastating economic crisis of our time?

COVID-19 erupted in a macroeconomic environment that is a rich cocktail of economic contraction and contradiction. History teaches us that if we don’t pay attention to this — we risk underestimating the magnitude of the crisis that we face.


The Coronavirus pandemic erupted in a macroeconomic environment that is a rich cocktail of economic contraction and contradiction. History teaches us that if we don’t pay attention to this — we risk underestimating the magnitude of the crisis that we face.


The economic and humanitarian devastation being wrought by the COVID-19 crisis across the world, is currently being treated by the media and policy makers as an exceptional event.

Nearly all of the public domain estimates of its potential economic impact are based on lockdown calculations of the various sectors and, in some cases, the medical costs. However, the impact of the pandemic cannot be divorced from the existing national and international macroeconomic environment. It also cannot be separated from macroeconomic policy options and their potential unintended consequences.

The current reporting on the crisis masks a concerning fact; when the pandemic erupted — many economies were already on a downward trend. This may deepen the impact of the crisis and prolong the time it takes for most countries, South Africa included, to recover.

It helps set the scene to draw on the lessons and magnitude of major recessions and depressions over the last century, starting with the Great Depression, which began in 1929. This caused untold human tragedy by reducing incomes in the US by between 6% and 12% annually as that shock played itself out. The notable causes of that shock were price meltdowns in the stock and housing market; massive bank failures; a devastating drought; and poor policy. The latter included higher interest rates, contractionary fiscal policy and a trade war.

The Japanese ‘lost decade’ which started in the early 1990s and is yet to play itself out was similarly caused by price meltdowns in the stock and housing market; bank failures; and poor policy. The latter in this case was dominated by policy that was ‘too little, too late’.

The third important economic crisis was the so-called ‘Dot Com’ bubble of 2001/2. It was caused by a stock and housing market bubble. The end of the bubble was characterised by a price meltdown in the stock market and policy that was ‘too much, too soon’. It was these policy responses that were the fuel for the Financial Crisis starting 2008 where there were also massive stock and housing market bubbles. Again, the end of the bubble resulted in price meltdowns in the stock and housing market and massive bank failures. It also heralded in many countries breaking the rules of fiscal prudency and quantitative easing (QE) funding this fiscal imprudence. In the US this increase in QE was $3.5tn. In the Euro Zone it was €3.5tn.

So what do these historical examples have in common with what we are experiencing now? It was clear, by the end of last year, that most countries were on the verge of recession. The evidence can be seen in falling or negative GDP growth supported by various indicators including business confidence, consumer confidence, the PMI (Purchasing Manager’s Index) and the Baltic Dry index (which is indicative of world trade). GDP growth in January 2020 was sitting at around 0.4% in Germany, 0.5% in France, 0,4% in Japan, and 1% in the UK. Although China appeared fairly strong at 6%, the numbers were dropping month-to-month, which was the case in the US as well, where 2.3% was noted in the beginning of the year. In South Africa, there was only 0.2% growth in 2019 and so it began the year technically in recession.

Stock markets can be expected to reflect underlying economic conditions. The economic outlook determines potential sales and profits. These influence corporate values and dividends and are reflected in stock prices. Strikingly this was not the case. Stock markets boomed throughout 2019 — The US, Germany, France, China, Russia, even the UK (in the face of Brexit) and Japan had markets which were irrationally buoyant. The funding for this exuberance? The on-going policy driven economic stimulus in the rich world.

It is this rich cocktail of economic contraction and contradiction that was the macroeconomic environment in which the Corona pandemic found itself. The immediate consequence was a stock market meltdown of similar proportions to previous economic shocks. The Dow Jones drop was similar to the Financial Crisis and the Nasdaq to the Dot.Com bubble. The UK, Dutch and South African? Market drops were very similar to those in the Financial Crisis. This heralded the onset of macroeconomic shocks that would reinforce the Corona impact with devastating economic consequences. The world was poised on the verge of an economic meltdown not just because of Covid-19 but also because countries had already entered recession and then suffered a devastating stock market meltdown. All of this left people feeling very poor.

Enter government with necessary policy responses and stimulus packages. In the US these are currently estimated at $2.4tn and it appears that this will be funded through QE. This should be seen in contrast to the $3.5tn QE between 2009 — 2014 after the Financial Crisis. Current Euro Zone plans are €500bn with an opaque funding mechanism. This must be compared to the €3.5tn QE between 2009 and 2019.

The immediate response to this policy stimulus? A massive stock market rebound. It was the policy responses to the Dot.Com bubble that fuelled the Financial Crisis. It was the policy responses to the Financial Crisis that fuelled the stock market bubble of 2019. The reader can draw their own conclusion about what the policy response to the Coronavirus is doing to stock markets. To date the policy responses to COVID-19 are smaller than those to the Financial Crisis. These have however only been over the last three months. The policy responses to the Financial Crisis continued over nearly a decade. The conclusions are surely self-evident.

As a footnote, any forecast of the direct economic impact of the pandemic is going to be wrong. There may however be some merit to making a minimum estimate. A simple ‘back of envelope’ calculation can be done on a sector-by-sector basis. Imagine a five-week lockdown in which the main sectors contract, over a quarter, by, for example, 45% in mining, 35% in manufacturing and 35% in tourism. Imagine further that all sectors recover over the course of a year to identical levels as at the beginning of 2020. There will be an annual drop in GDP of 10%. This minimum estimate is little different to the worst international economic crisis of all time — the Great Depression.

By looking at the pandemic in isolation from both short trends in local and international economies and existing structural weaknesses in international economies, we risk not being properly prepared for the magnitude of what we are facing. What many countries around the world - and South Africa for sure - are likely looking at is another financial crisis - this time brought on by a natural phenomenon - COVID-19. But this event, coming as it does on the heels of a declining global economy may prove to be more devastating than the other big financial crises of our times. This data shows an imperative on government to stimulate the economy to recover as soon as possible to limit the effects of this crisis, by introducing policies that support local businesses and promote the rebuilding of local industries in order to limit the potential damage.

Barry Standish, a former UCT GSB economist, is a founding partner at StratEcon, a leading South African economics consultancy with more than three decades of experience in Africa. This article is based on a talk that he gave to alumni of the UCT Graduate School of Business in April.


MORE ON COVID-19

Breaking point for South Africa’s youth
COVID-19

Breaking point for South Africa’s youth

COVID-19 has exacerbated the pressures on the mental health of young people; we have to intervene now if we are to avert a national disaster.

Read Article
Posted on 11 October 2021 by UCT GSB Press Office
John Luiz - epidemic media
COVID-19

Q&A with John Luiz on the future of globalisation

The extraordinary spread of the Covid-19 virus over the past year has highlighted various vulnerabilities associated with globalisation. We asked the UCT GSB's Prof John Luiz for his views on the future of this model.

Read Article
Posted on 25 January 2021 by John Luiz
Cape Talk
COVID-19

Dr Beverly Shrand chats to Kieno Kammies about a new CEMS report on leadership

A new report released today by the CEMS Global Alliance in Management Education shares insights and recommendations for business leaders, educators and young professionals for 2021 and beyond.

Read Article
Posted on 19 January 2021 by Beverly Shrand
Advancing tech - media
COVID-19

As COVID-19 gets more people working from home, cybercriminals zoom in

The COVID-19 pandemic is accelerating digital trends to change our very notions of work and office. This presents both opportunities and threats - particularly when it comes to cybersecurity.

Read Article
Posted on 25 September 2020 by Sharron McPherson
latest update from uct - Media
COVID-19

Latest updates from UCT

UCT is taking the possible threat of infection in our community extremely seriously. This page will be updated regularly with the latest information relating to COVID-19.

Read Article
Posted on 1 July 2020 by UCT GSB Press Office
Bertha survey SA youth - Media
COVID-19

SA’s youth hit hard by COVID-19

A survey conducted with young South Africans has revealed that many have had to borrow money to survive as a result of COVID-19, with a significant number plunged deeper into unemployment.

Read Article
Posted on 25 June 2020 by UCT GSB Press Office
WHAT’S BREWING DURING LOCKDOWN? - Media
COVID-19

What’s Brewing During Lockdown?

The South African craft beer market could be very different post lockdown.

Read Article
Posted on 25 May 2020 by UCT GSB Press Office
kw new - media
COVID-19

Mastering the art of the virtual meeting

Getting the most out of virtual meetings demands more than a mastery of new tech, it’s about creating human connections across the digital ether.

Read Article
Posted on 11 May 2020 by Kumeshnee West
penish african man - media
COVID-19

Alumni webinar series: Five implications of the coronavirus for business leaders

Professor Ralph Hamann hosted a webinar exploring five long-term implications for business leaders due to COVID-19.

Read Article
Posted on 8 May 2020 by Ralph Hamann
barry standish - media
COVID-19

Webinar: The broader economic implications of COVID-19

Former UCT GSB economist, Barry Standish, hosted a free webinar in April for UCT GSB alumni on the broader financial and economic implications of COVID-19.

Read Article
Posted on 7 May 2020 by UCT GSB Press Office
Virtual meetings Medi
COVID-19

3 Tips for managing and motivating teams during COVID-19

The current crisis is offering many businesses in South Africa an opportunity to rethink how they manage and motivate their teams for the better.

Read Article
Posted on 6 May 2020 by Christina Opperman-Swart
How COVID-19 will permanently change - Media
COVID-19

How COVID-19 will permanently change the way we work

What trends will be accelerated, what will die away, and what new trends will appear? And what’s the most important thing organisations need to do now to prepare? We ask three people in the know.

Read Article
Posted on 6 May 2020 by UCT GSB Press Office
Why downgrading countries - Media
COVID-19

Coronavirus - an excuse to downgrade African countries deep into junk

A number of rating agencies have downgraded emerging market economies during the COVID-19 pandemic. Their actions have raised the question: why do so during a crisis?

Read Article
Posted on 3 May 2020 by Misheck Mutize
inequality - Media
COVID-19

This Freedom Day let’s commit to the change that enhances the freedom for all

On Freedom Day this year, the national lockdown and response to the COVID-19 pandemic, are holding up a mirror to society and forcing us to confront our faults and weaknesses.

Read Article
Posted on 28 April 2020 by Athol Williams
Mignon business aglity - Media
COVID-19

Strategic agility is key to business survival during this crisis — and beyond

As the COVID-19 pandemic advances, some companies have been able to change strategic focus to stay afloat in new and innovative ways. Here’s what their actions have to teach the rest of us.

Read Article
Posted on 24 April 2020 by Mignon Reyneke
Cyril board - Media
COVID-19

Trust in times of crisis: Why we need to trust our governments

The Edelman Trust Barometer released in January, exposed some rather discouraging truths, not only about the global state of the world, but also about South Africa.

Read Article
Posted on 22 April 2020 by Badri Zolfaghari
BOX THINKING - Media
COVID-19

Video interview - Out of the box thinking can help small businesses weather the storm

Dr Tim London chats to the Bertha Centre's Natasha Dinham, about a number of measures investors can take to ameliorate the effects of the COVID -19 crisis.

Read Article
Posted on 22 April 2020 by UCT GSB Press Office
How can small bus - MEDIA
COVID-19

Video interview - How can Govt better support small businesses during COVID-19?

Dr Tim London interviewed UCT students and researchers, Zaakir Essa and Georgina Borros from Phaphama on their study of a particular group of small businesses that are facing real threats from the impacts of COVID-19.

Read Article
Posted on 22 April 2020 by UCT GSB Press Office
life after lockdown - Media
COVID-19

Life after lockdown: Welcome to physical distancing and the contactless economy

When lockdown ends, it is likely that people are going to want to have safe spaces to meet up in and have fun. What can visitor attractions do now to make sure they are ready?

Read Article
Posted on 14 April 2020 by Sabine Lehmann
Mehluli_profile - Media
COVID-19

Strong leadership in times of crisis

Taking the reins of Zimbabwe’s largest building society during the Covid-19 pandemic has certainly been challenging, but GSB alumnus Mehluli Mpofu believes that his leadership philosophy built on team work and problem-solving will help steer the institution he leads through these trying times.

Read Article
Posted on 14 April 2020 by UCT GSB Press Office
War lost - Media
COVID-19

We are not at war with COVID-19

The rhetoric of war, and the unfortunate term ‘lockdown’ are even more misplaced in this crisis because it takes people to change a society, not simply putting stringent rules or regulations in place and enforcing them through the barrel of a gun.

Read Article
Posted on 14 April 2020 by Camaren Peter
HOW ARE COMPANIES ADAPTING - Media
COVID-19

Video interview - How are companies adapting their businesses to cope with COVID-19?

Dr Tim London spoke with Mignon Reyneke, an associate professor of Digital Marketing at the UCT GSB, about some of the companies that are trying to deal with the fallout of COVID-19 by doing things differently.

Read Article
Posted on 14 April 2020 by UCT GSB Press Office
Health Needle - Media
COVID-19

We need to mobilise communities in the global fight against coronavirus

While scientists and big pharma work on vaccines, innovations and solutions developed at the community level will be key to slowing the spread of the virus.

Read Article
Posted on 14 April 2020 by Katusha De Villiers
Cape Talk logo - Media
COVID-19

How investors can support small businesses through the COVID-19 lockdown

The Bertha Centre’s Natasha Dinham spoke with Kieno Kammies at Cape Talk, about how investors can help small businesses through these challenging times.

Read Article
Posted on 9 April 2020 by Natasha Dinham
wet market - Media
COVID-19

COVID-19's top five long-term implications for business leaders

The spread of the pandemic has brought to the fore the need for business leaders to recognise the crucial interdependencies between business and its environmental, social, and governance context.

Read Article
Posted on 8 April 2020 by Ralph Hamann
everything sean goseel - MEDIA
COVID-19

Everything has changed: The world and South Africa's economy after COVID-19

The Covid-19 pandemic has changed the world: It is possible that it will take years for the global economy to recover, which will have dire implications for South Africa’s economic prospects.

Read Article
Posted on 6 April 2020 by UCT GSB Press Office
Small business - Media
COVID-19

How investors can support small businesses through the COVID-19 lockdown

For a small business, twenty-one days may be as long as it takes to close its doors forever. But investors might just have the tools to make sure that doesn’t happen.

Read Article
Posted on 2 April 2020 by Natasha Dinham
Expressions of Exclusion - Media
COVID-19

Human Rights in the South African Workplace: From Fighting Apartheid to Tackling Exclusion

South African organisations have made great strides in achieving more diversity and transformation. However, too many people still feel excluded in workplaces.

Read Article
Posted on 31 March 2020 by Kurt April
Resources - Media
COVID-19

Resources for information related to COVID-19

COVID-19 ("Coronavirus") Information and Resources

Read Article
Posted on 27 March 2020 by UCT GSB Press Office
Kurt April Corono - Media
COVID-19

Great leaders are made in times of crises; who will step up?

The COVID-19 crisis is giving leaders everywhere a test of unimaginable proportions. Right now we need calm, agile and decisive people at the helm across all sectors to ensure that we survive and go on to thrive again - and President Ramaphosa is setting a good example.

Read Article
Posted on 26 March 2020 by Kurt April
social echeosion - Media
COVID-19

Could the Covid-19 crisis offer us a window of opportunity to build social cohesion?

A national disaster declared on top of a technical recession and a standoff between the ANC and its alliance partners means that we can expect the SA economy will remain in a downward cycle for the foreseeable future — our only hope lies in building social cohesion in the face of crisis.

Read Article
Posted on 25 March 2020 by Sean Gossel
globalisation- Media
COVID-19

The globalisation of an epidemic and the epidemic of globalisation

COVID-19 respects no borders and has laid bare some of the vulnerabilities of globalisation. Going forward, we need to look more deeply at how to build a world that protects global supply chains more effectively — and the all people that depend upon them.

Read Article
Posted on 25 March 2020 by John Luiz
Quad Area - Media
COVID-19

Updates for Staff

The health, safety, and well-being of the UCT GSB community is our top priority. This page will be regularly updated to keep staff informed.

Read Article
Posted on 24 March 2020 by UCT GSB Press Office
COVID-19 could be a chance to rethink - Media
COVID-19

COVID-19 could be a chance to rethink, disrupt and plan for the future of your business

While COVID-19 is expected to wreak havoc on the South African economy, the full extent of this is yet to be determined. But even in crisis, there are always opportunities for innovation.

Read Article
Posted on 23 March 2020 by Mikael Samuelsson
Remote Working - Media
COVID-19

COVID-19 has made remote working the new normal - why this might be good for productivity

SA lags behind the working-from-home curve, but the combination of coronavirus and loadshedding may be changing that. Fortunately, studies show it can improve productivity and protect the bottom line.

Read Article
Posted on 19 March 2020 by Sharron McPherson
Cape Talk logo - Media
COVID-19

Q&A with Tim London on the impact of COVID-19 on education

As the coronavirus continues to play a prominent role in our lives, we are forced to do things differently. With schools closing this week, this is making online learning very much a reality for the immediate future. But is South Africa ready for this?

Read Article
Posted on 18 March 2020 by Tim London